Menu

An Ex-CPF Employee Exposes the 3 Biggest Complaints Singaporeans Have About Their CPF Accounts

391302848_2250a1fa4d_b

Few questions divide Singaporeans as much as this one – What is CPF used for? As you process your own answer to that question, chances are the words “retirement,” “housing,” healthcare” and maybe “Ponzi scheme” are running through your head.

But no matter what function(s) you think CPF serves, everyone faces the reality of having to pay their “dues” to keep the system going. That means contributing 20% of your salary (up to age 50) every month to a scheme that only benefits those who vastly surpass the current minimum balance of $148K.

Sadly, more Singaporeans who have money in CPF and need it can’t even touch it.

An ex-CPF employee named “Brian” (who wishes to remain anonymous for very obvious reasons), who deals with the valid concerns of Singaporeans daily, was kind enough to help us shed some light on what Singaporeans complain about most when it comes to their CPF accounts. Here are Singaporeans’ 3 biggest complaints about their CPF accounts:

1. It’s Nearly Impossible to Access Your Retirement Account (RA) Funds

The biggest limiting factor people have when it comes to their CPF accounts is the fact that their Retirement Account (RA) funds are about as inaccessible as Area 51 until you reach the drawdown, which varies from 62 to 65 depending on your year of birth. The problem with having an inaccessible RA account is that it leaves Singaporeans still servicing their home loan with their CPF in a helpless situation because:

  1. Retrenchment: No income means they can no longer make contributions into their Ordinary Accounts (OA).
  2. Contribution level: The contribution level decreases significantly after 55, making it harder to meet the minimum cash component in RA.

It’s sad, there were several occasions when we had to direct Singaporeans to HDB or the banks because our hands were tied – we couldn’t release their funds to them even though they may have thousands in their RA to help with their home loan repayments,” says Brian. Ironically, the only exceptions for using your RA funds involve purchasing property under the following conditions:

  1. You can only use the excess in your RA AFTER setting aside the minimum cash component, which is currently $148K.
  2. Of that $148K, you’ll need to maintain $74K in your RA, with the excess (excluding annual interests) being available for the purchase of property.

*Note on property purchases: According to Brian, there is a way for you to use your OA towards purchasing property. If you have booked a BTO flat before turning 55, you can write in to CPF to have funds from your OA reserved for the purchase. In fact, Singaporeans have been successful in having these requests approved.

2. You Can’t Withdraw As Much from CPF at Age 55

Just a few years ago, if you turned 55 before 2009, you could have withdrawn 50% of your combined OA and Special Account (SA) funds! So if you had today’s current minimum sum of $148K, you could withdraw $74,000. Then in 2009, the limit dropped to 40%. And then… well, I think you know where this is going right?

Let’s just say that CPF reduced the withdrawal limit faster than an Indonesian palm plantation owner reduces forestland. Today, if you don’t have the full minimum sum of $148K – you ONLY get $5K. The rest gets sent over to your RA, which you probably won’t see for another 7 to 10 years. The biggest complaints Brian received about the inability of some Singaporeans to get more than $5K were:

  • Couldn’t pay off debts: Singaporeans who were financially troubled and had debts to pay off could not pay them even though they had thousands of dollars in their RA.
  • In danger of home repossession: Singaporeans who were having trouble keeping up with their home loan repayments due to retrenchment or financial difficulty couldn’t access the money they needed to maintain their repayments even though they might have had $50K in their RA.
  • Couldn’t go on pilgrimage: Many elderly Muslims who were waiting till age 55 to use their funds to go on pilgrimage (Hajj) were left disappointed when the amount they could withdraw wasn’t enough.

*Note on pledging your property: Brian points out that if you’ve used your CPF to purchase a home, you can opt to pledge or increase the pledge of your property. So if you just turn 55 this year and you’ve got the full minimum sum of $148K, you can pledge your property up to $74K, freeing up the “excess” $74K in your CPF for withdrawal.

3. There Are Times When You CAN’T Use CPF for Housing

When you buy a home, there’s a limit to how much CPF you can use to purchase a home, called the Valuation Limit (VL). The VL is determined by the lower value of either the market price or the valuation price of a home, and you cannot withdraw more than 120% of the VL, which is called the Withdrawal Limit (WL). So what happens when you reach the VL of your home?

If you’re below 55, you’ll need to maintain either half the prevailing minimum sum cash component (Your OA+SA+SA investments) or the minimum sum cash component in your RA if you’re over 55 (and you can only use your RA excess to service your home loan). If you don’t follow these conditions, you CAN’T use your CPF to service your home loan.

Not knowing when you can’t use your CPF to service your home loan is a huge reason why people contact CPF, especially when Singaporeans:

  • Reach their VL before age 55 and haven’t maintained half of their prevailing minimum sum cash component (OA+SA+SA investments).
  • Reach their VL after age 55 and haven’t maintained their minimum sum cash component in their RA (only RA excess can be used!).
  • Surpass their WL.

 

CPF Staff Are There to Help, But They Don’t Make Policy

“We understand that CPF needs to be more flexible in allowing Singaporeans to use their funds. What’s the point of having thousands of ‘untouchable’ dollars set aside for retirement when Singaporeans are dealing with financial difficulty now? But we do our best to help people out as much as possible,” says Brian.Brian also stated that the complaints above made up about 70% of their total communications.

That’s A LOT of daily gripes to deal with. Most Singaporeans have their reasons to complain about CPF. If you’ve read Dear CPF: Give Me Back My Money, you know just a few of the many grievances people have with the scheme. But before you call up or email CPF to give them a piece of your mind, please remember that the hard working employees don’t set policy – they’re there to help you as best as they can.

 

What complaints or praise do you have about CPF? Share your experience on Facebook! And to find even more useful information on everything personal finance, visit MoneySmart today! Image Credits: fox2mike

Jeff Cuellar

I'm known by many titles: copywriter, published author, literary connoisseur, ex- U.S. Army intelligence analyst, and Champion of Capua. But at MoneySmart.sg, I'm known as the Senior Writer. I love hearing from my readers, so drop me a line at jeff @ moneysmart.sg You can also follow me on Twitter @ https://twitter.com/JeffCuellar

Jeff Cuellar on Google+
  • Chin

    Meant for retirement? So you need the govt to hold your hand to plan your retirement savings plan. Do you need help tying your shoelaces too?

  • Zheng

    This is because many irresponsible old men got the CPF money and spent in Batam while the old women spent it on Cruise to no way casino. So when they need money for their livelihood, the govt will have to give help which means tax payers’ money will have to used on these irresponsible people. Look at europe, so many countries went bankrupt because of money spent on irresponsible people.

  • Zheng

    Pls sign a form and said you do not need any govt help in the future, not even a single cent.

  • Zheng

    Pls sign a form to indicate that you will not use a single cent from the govt, that is tax payer money.

  • Zheng

    Ask your sis to sign a declaration that will not use a single cent from the govt which means tax payer money.

  • Zheng

    One need to be financial prudent and do not overstretch our financial obligation.

  • Zheng

    When they run out of money, they will ask their govt for help and that is why so many european countries went bankrupt.

  • David Tay

    Jeff, great article. It really highlights the need to be prudent with your home purchase and plan carefully. Even with the 120% VL in place, your loan should be able to cover the cost of your home if you had paid enough for the first deposit.

    Unfortunately, if you ever find yourself jobless and unable to service your housing loan pass age 55, you cant use any of the money in your RA. CPF board is inflexible in that way. Then again, it should remind us to be more careful with our housing purchase. Perhaps we should choose loan repayment plans that end before we reach age 55.

  • Ivy Tan

    That’s what taxes are for. Not CPF. CPF is a financial planning scheme, not a revenue source for the government. Get your facts right.

0